Is centrism doomed? The cautionary tale of Howard Schultz — and the surprising promise of a populist center

kAmkDEC@?8mw@H2C5 $49F=EK DE@@5 :? E96 <:E496?6EE6 @7 2 4@249 3FD @?6 27E6C?@@? :? pAC:=[ DE:CC:?8 4@7766 8C@F?5D :? 2 uC6?49 AC6DD]k^DEC@?8m Q%9:D :D vF2E6>2=2?[Q 96 D2:5] Q$F?\5C:65] xEVD D@ 8@@5] xE 92D 2=>@DE 2 3=F636CCJ 7=2G@C[ 3FE :EVD G6CJ ?2EFC2=] '6CJ 7=@C2=]Qk^Am

kAm(6 H6C6 C@25\EC:AA:?8 E@ E96 |6I:42? 3@C56C E9C@F89 pC:K@?2VD $@?@C2? s6D6CE[ H9:=6 E96 7@C>6C $E2C3F4<D rt~ 4@?D:56C65 2 CF? 7@C AC6D:56?E 2D 2 Q46?EC:DE :?56A6?56?E]Q x H2D HC:E:?8 2 A:646 23@FE 46?EC:D>[ 2?5 H96E96C :E H2D 5625[ 2?5 H2?E65 E@ E2=< E@ :ED =2E6DE 2G2E2C] %96 G6CJ ?6IE 52J[ $49F=EK H@F=5 D=:A 2 5:D< :? 9:D 324<[ =625:?8 E@ E9C66 DFC86C:6D :? EH@ >@?E9D] w:D 42>A2:8? H@F=5 8@ 52C< 7@C E96 DF>>6Cj :? >:5\yF?6[ $49F=EK H@F=5 6>2:= 9:D DFAA@CE6CD[ AC@>:D:?8 E92E 96V5 36 Q324< :? E@F49 27E6C {23@C s2J]Q xE ?@H 2AA62CD E92E $49F=EK :D H2:E:?8 E@ D66 9@H 72C =67E E96 s6>@4C2ED >@G6 367@C6 7:8FC:?8 @FE H96E96C 9:D 3:5 >2<6D 2?J AC24E:42= D6?D6 \ 2?5 H96E96C p>6C:42? 56>@4C24J DE:== ?665D 2 46?EC:DE D2G:@C]k^Am

kAmqFE E92E H@F=5 2== 4@>6 =2E6C] ~? E9:D 3=:DE6C:?8 |@?52J[ $49F=EK H2D @AE:>:DE:42==J AC6DD:?8 29625[ EC2G6=:?8 :? 2 DA24:@FD 2?5 H6==\2AA@:?E65 4@249 3FD[ H9:49[ 244@C5:?8 E@ E96 5C:G6C[ H2D AC6G:@FD=J 4@>>2?566C65 3J z6D92] p=@?8 7@C E96 C:56 H6C6 D6G6C2= >6>36CD @7 9:D E96?\a_\A6CD@? 6?E@FC286[ 2>@?8 E96> @?6 9:89\AC@7:=6 A@=:E:42= 4@?DF=E2?E[ EH@ AC6DD 2:56D[ @?6 EC:A 5:C64E@C[ G:56@8C2A96CD[ $&' 5C:G6CD[ :?7@C>2= 25G:D6CD W:]6][ 7C:6?5DX[ D64FC:EJ A6CD@??6= 2?5 D4FCCJ:?8 Q25G2?46 A6@A=6]Q %96C6 H6C6 6:89E E6=6G:D:@?D @? E96 3FD[ :?4=F5:?8 @?6 :? E96 32E9C@@>[ 2== EF?65 E@ r}} 7@@E286 @7 E96 42E965C2= @7 }@EC6 s2>6 @? 7:C6]k^Am

kAm$49F=EK[ ed[ :D =62? 2?5 2E9=6E:4] w6 =@A6D 2C@F?5 \ @C 2E =62DE 96 5:5 367@C6 9:D :?;FCJ \ H:E9 2 =2?<J[ 25@=6D46?E 82:E] w6 E6?5D E@ H62C 2 =@@< @7 DE625J[ :7 G242?E[ C6D@=G6] w6VD ?@E 2 32CC6= @7 =2F89D[ 3FE 96 42? 5@ AC6EEJ 8@@5 DA@CED 32?E6C] Ww6 FD65 E@ @H? E96 }qpVD $FA6C$@?:4D[ E96? D@=5 E96 E62> E@ 2 8C@FA @7 ~<=29@>2 :?G6DE@CD[ 56G2DE2E:?8 $62EE=6 7@C6G6C]X w6 C6=:6D @? A@=:D965 2?645@E6D \ 9:D 86?C6 :D A2C23=6D @7 3FD:?6DD DF446DD \ E92E 96VD @3G:@FD=J E@=5 4@F?E=6DD E:>6D] qFE 96V== @442D:@?2==J DFCAC:D6 >6 H:E9 2 D2=EJ 2D:56[ =:<6 H96? 96 =@@<65 FA 2E r}} 2?5 2D<65[ @7792?5[ Q(92E 92AA6?65 E@ q6E@nQk^Am

kAm~? E96 3FD[ H6 H6C6 5:D4FDD:?8 9:D AC@A@D2= E@ 5:D2==@H E96 4@?7:C>2E:@? @7 2?J $FAC6>6 r@FCE ?@>:?66D ?@E DFAA@CE65 3J EH@\E9:C5D @7 E96 $6?2E6 \ 2? :562 E92E =65 E96 AF?5:E 4=2DD E@ 4@?56>? 9:> 2D 2 3=FDE6C:?8 ?2:7 H:E9 D42?E F?56CDE2?5:?8 @7 4@?E6>A@C2CJ A@=:E:4D] Q!6@A=6 E9@F89E E9:D H2D ?@E C62=:DE:4[Q 96 D2:5] QqFE :E D9@F=5 36 C62=:DE:4]Q %96 4C:E:4:D> 3277=65 9:>] Q%96 H9@=6 4@C6 AFCA@D6 2?5 C62D@? H9J xV> 96C6 :D E@ ECJ 2?5 D6CG6 E96 p>6C:42? A6@A=6 36EE6C[ E@ 8:G6 E96> H92E E96J 56D6CG6i 2 36EE6C A@=:E:42= 4=2DD[Q 96 D2:5] w6 E:4<65 @77 E96 BF2=:E:6D 2 A@=:E:42= 4=2DD D9@F=5 92G6i Qw@?6DE[ 72:C[ D:?46C6[ ECFE97F=[ 2FE96?E:4] %92E :D H92E H6VG6 =@DE]Qk^Am

kAm%9:D DA2C<65 2 E9@F89Ei Q~G6C E96 H66<6?5 x C625 H92E v6@C86 (2D9:?8E@? D2:5 \ C6C625 :E \ H96? 96 H2C?65 E96 4@F?ECJ 23@FE 724E:@?D[Q $49F=EK C64@F?E65] Qw6 H2D H2C?:?8 23@FE 6I24E=J H96C6 H6 2C6 C:89E ?@H] p?5 E96? =2DE H66<[ H96? H6 H6C6 :? z2?D2D[ H6VC6 C625:?8 H92E t:D6?9@H6C HC@E6 :? `heh[ :? 9:D @H? 92?5[ 2 DE@CJ :? #6256CVD s:86DE[ 23@FE E96 A@H6C 2?5 :>A@CE2?46 @7 E96 >:55=6] w6 D2:5i %96 6IEC6>6D @? 3@E9 D:56D 2C6 :? E96 8FEE6CD] *@F D9@F=5 C625 :E] w6 H2D E2=<:?8 23@FE H92E :E >62?D E@ 36 2 46?EC:DEPQk^Am

kAmx? a_`g[ AC@76DD:?8 2=2C> 2E E96 5:C64E:@? @7 E96 4@F?ECJ[ $49F=EK DE6AA65 5@H? 7C@> 9:D =@?8E:>6 A6C49 2E@A $E2C3F4<D] x? =2E6 y2?F2CJ[ 96 2??@F?465 5FC:?8 2 Qe_ |:?FE6DQ :?E6CG:6H E92E 96 H2D D6C:@FD=J 4@?D:56C:?8 2 AC6D:56?E:2= CF?] (92E 7@==@H65 H2D 2 A6C:@5 @7 DE2886C:?8 ?682E:G6 AF3=:4:EJ] p 3:A2CE:D2? 4@?D6?DFD 7@C>65i $49F=EK H2D 2? 68@>2?:24 H9@D6 E9:C5\A2CEJ G2?:EJ 42>A2:8? H@F=5 5@ ?@E9:?8 3FE C66=64E E96 AC6D:56?E 96 AC@76DD65 E@ =@2E96] s@?2=5 %CF>A A:=65 @?[ EH66E:?8 E92E $49F=EK Q5@6D?VE 92G6 E96 8FEDQ E@ CF? \ 2? 2EE6>AE[ C6A@CE65=J[ E@ 8@25 9:> :?E@ E96 C246]k^Am

kAm%96 A@D:E:G6 4@G6C286 E92E 5:5 >2E6C:2=:K6 H2D?VE 2=H2JD 4@?G:?4:?8] $49F=EK :D Q@?6 @7 G6CJ 76H A6@A=6 @? E96 A=2?6E H9@ 24EF2==J 925 E96 G:D:@? E@ EC2?D7@C> E96 H2J H6 =:G6[Q HC@E6 *29@@ }6HD 4@=F>?:DE |2EE q2:[ :? 2 C2C6 AC@\$49F=EK @A\65] Qq6=:6G6 :E @C ?@E[ >:==6??:2=D[ 367@C6 $E2C3F4<D 42>6 2=@?8[ >66E:?8 @G6C 27E6C?@@? 4@7766 H2D?VE 2 E9:?8 :? p>6C:42]Q x? u63CF2CJ[ x H6?E E@ 2 $49F=EK "U2>Ajp 2E E96 uC66 {:3C2CJ @7 !9:=256=A9:2[ >@56C2E65 3J 7@C>6C (66<=J $E2?52C5 65:E@C q:== zC:DE@=] p7E6C E96 6G6?E 4@?4=F565[ 2 H@>2? H@C<65 96C H2J E9C@F89 2 >2DD @7 3@5:6D E@ :?EC@5F46 96CD6=7 E@ $49F=EK] Qw:[ 9@H 2C6 J@FnQ D96 D2:5 2D E96J D9@@< 92?5D] Qx ;FDE 92G6 E@ D2J[ :EV== <:== >6 :7 J@F C66=64E s@?2=5 %CF>A] *@F 2C6 C62==J 52?86C@FD] *@F H:== <:== FD]Q Ww6 AC@>:D65 96C 96 H@F=5?VE]Xk^Am

kAm&?56E6CC65[ $49F=EK C6?E65 E96 3FD :? pAC:= 2?5 3682? EC2G6=:?8 E96 4@F?ECJ] %96 E@FC H@F=5 36 2 >2C<65 4@?EC2DE E@ E96 %' DA@ED \ 2 u@I }6HD E@H? 92==[ 2 r}} E@H? 92==[ Q|@C?:?8 y@6Q \ H96C6 96V5 AC6G:@FD=J 2C8F65 9:D 42D6[ 2D H6== 2D E96 3:8\4:EJ 3@@< E2=<D :? H9:49 96V5 AC@>@E65 9:D ?6H >6>@:C[ QuC@> E96 vC@F?5 &AQ W9:D E9:C5 >6>@:C @G6C2==[ 2?5 D64@?5[ 27E6C `hhfVD Q!@FC *@FC w62CE x?E@ xE[Q E@ 6>A=@J 2 4@7766\E96>65 E:E=6X] x?DE625[ E96 C@25 EC:A H2D 56D:8?65 E@ 766= 7@=<DJi %96 3:==:@?2:C6 H@F=5 AFE @? 2 A2:C @7 ;62?D 2?5 DE286 2? :?7@C>2= =:DE6?:?8 E@FC H:E9 G@E6CD]k^Am

kAmq67@C6 x ;@:?65 E96 E@FC :? pC:K@?2[ $49F=EKVD AC6DD =:2:D@? C6BF6DE65 E92E $49F=EK 2?5 x 7:CDE >66E :? }6H *@C< r:EJ E@ 766= 6249 @E96C @FE] %96 >66E:?8 E@@< A=246 :? E96 |:5E@H? @77:46 @7 2 3@FE:BF6 :?G6DE>6?E 32?< CF? 3J 2 4=@D6 7C:6?5 @7 $49F=EKVD] u@C D@>6@?6 C@FE:?6=J E2CC65 2D 2? @FE\@7\E@F49 3:==:@?2:C6[ E9:D DECF4< >6 2D 2 325 =@@<[ 3FE :E H2D 2E =62DE 2? 9@?6DE C67=64E:@? @7 9:D 3C2?5] ~? E96 DEF>A[ $49F=EK 72G@CD 3C@25[ 3=2?5 AC@4=2>2E:@?Dj :? A6CD@?[ 96 42? 36 D92CA6C] w6 DA6?E @FC 92=7\9@FC 36>@2?:?8 E96 =67EH2C5 E:=E @7 E96 s6>@4C2E:4 !2CEJ 96V5 C646?E=J 232?5@?65i |65:42C6\7@C\2== H2D :?D2?6] q6C?:6 $2?56CD H2D 2 Q?FE ;@3]Q p?5 D@ 7@CE9]k^Am

kAmx >6E 9:> 2 H66< =2E6C :? $4@EED52=6[ pC:K@?2[ 2E E96 924:6?52\=:<6 AC@A6CEJ E92E 9@FD6D E96 =@42= r92>36C @7 r@>>6C46] w6 82G6 @77 2 A2A2= G:36 2D 96 D=@H=J >256 9:D H2J E9C@F89 E96 3F:=5:?8VD 4@FCEJ2C5[ 7=2?<65 3J 9:D 6?E@FC286[ H2G:?8 E@ @?=@@<6CD] u@C 2== 9:D 2AA2C6?E E@I:4:EJ[ $49F=EK >2?2865 E@ 2EEC24E D@>6 :?EC:8F:?8 3:A2CE:D2? E2=6?E E@ 9:D E62>[ 49:67 2>@?8 E96> $E6G6 $49>:5E[ E96 32=5\5@>65 @A6C2E:G6 ?@E23=6 7@C DE66C:?8 E96 |4r2:?\!2=:? AC6D:56?E:2= 42>A2:8? 2?5[ >@C6 C646?E=J[ 232?5@?:?8 E96 v~! :? AC@E6DE @G6C %CF>A] Wp>@?8 E96 @E96CD H2D q:== qFCE@?[ 2 56AFEJ AC6DD D64C6E2CJ F?56C q2C24< ~32>2]X w:C:?8 A6@A=6 =:<6 $49>:5E =6?E 4C656?46 E@ E96 :562[ A@AF=2C 2>@?8 42>A2:8? C6A@CE6CD[ E92E $49F=EKVD @A6C2E:@? :D 6DD6?E:2==J 2 ;@3D AC@8C2> 7@C E96 A@=:E:42==J 9@>6=6DD 2?5 @AA@CEF?:DE:4] qFE E96 AC@76DD:@?2=:D> @7 E96 @A6C2E:@? 82G6 9:D >@E@C4256 E96 D4277@=5:?8 @7 AC6D:56?E:2= D6C:@FD?6DD \ H9:49 >2J 92G6 366? 2== 96 H2?E65 E@ 4@?G6J[ 2E E9:D DE286[ E@ 2 D<6AE:42= AF3=:4]k^Am

kAmx? $4@EED52=6[ 255C6DD:?8 =@42= 3FD:?6DDA6@A=6[ $49F=EK 7C2>65 E96 4FCC6?E 7:6=5 2D 2? :>A@DD:3=6 49@:46 36EH66? EH@ 96==:D9 6IEC6>6D] ~? E96 C:89E 2C6 %CF>A 2?5 E96 #6AF3=:42?D] p>@?8 @E96C D:?D[ =:<6 E9C62E6?:?8 E@ 4=@D6 E96 3@C56C[ E96 AC6D:56?E 92D 5:D8C2465 9:D A2CEJ 3J 232?5@?:?8 :ED 4=2:> E@ 7:D42= C6DA@?D:3:=:EJ[ $49F=EK D2:5i Q(6VC6 ?@E 8@:?8 E@ 92G6 E96 >@?6J E@ :?G6DE :? E96 49:=5C6? 2?5 E96 8C2?549:=5C6?]Q |62?H9:=6[ E96 s6>@4C2ED 2C6 7C62<:?8 9:> @FE H:E9 E96 D@4:2=:D>] uC@> E96C6[ 96 A:G@E65 E@ 8C2?56C E96>6D[ C6>2C<:?8 E92E 96 4@F=5?VE C642== E96 =2DE :?DE2?46 @7 A@=:E:42= QDE2E6D>2?D9:AQ D:?46 %:A ~V}6:== 2?5 #@?2=5 #6282? AFE 2D:56 E96:C 5:776C6?46D :? E96 `hg_D] ~?46 H6 H6C6 324< @? E96 3FD[ 9625:?8 D@FE9 E@H2C5 %F4D@?[ pC:K@?2[ $49F=EK C625 >6 @?6 BF@E6 7C@> yuz[ C676CC65 E@ EH@ DA66496D 3J #uz[ E96? D9@H65 >6 2 D@>36C :!9@?6 G:56@ 96 E@@< 2E 2 >:=:E2CJ 46>6E6CJ :? }@C>2?5J[ uC2?46[ H:E9 E2AD A=2J:?8 :? E96 324<8C@F?5] Q%96 p>6C:42? A6@A=6 2C6 =@?8:?8 7@C 492C24E6C[Q 96 E@=5 >6[ =2E6C @?] Q%96JVC6 =@?8:?8 7@C D@>6@?6 E@ ECFDE] %96JVC6 =@?8:?8 7@C ECFE9]Qk^Am

k46?E6CmkAmY Y Yk^Amk^46?E6Cm

kAmkDEC@?8mw@H2C5 $49F=EK 42>A2:8?D :? D6A:2]k^DEC@?8m r@=@C7F= 96 :D ?@E] x? @E96C H@C5D[ 96VD E96 =:G:?8 DE6C6@EJA6 @7 2 46?EC:DE]k^Am

kAmxEVD 92C5 E@ E9:?< @7 2 =6DD 4@>A6==:?8 E9:?8 E@ 36 C:89E ?@H E92? 2 46?EC:DE] !C64:D6=J 3642FD6 @7 E96 A6C>2?6?E 4C:D:D E92E 277=:4ED %CF>AVD (2D9:?8E@?[ $49F=EKVD A@I\@?\3@E9\9@FD6D D2?4E:>@?J 42? 766= ?@E ;FDE :?256BF2E6 3FE D=:89E=J ?2FD62E:?8] W$@>6E:>6D[ H96? xV5 2D< 9@H 96V5 255C6DD E9:D @C E92E AC@3=6> :? (2D9:?8E@?[ 96V5 ;FDE =@@< 2E >6 2?5 D2J[ Q{6256CD9:A]QX x? a_`e[ $49F=EK DFAA@CE65 w:==2CJ r=:?E@?[ @442D:@?2==J D6?5:?8 96C 25G:46 G:2 6>2:=] Q%96 42>A2:8? 766=D VJ6DE6C52J[V Q 96 HC@E6 :? 2 >:DD:G6 AF3=:D965 3J (:<:{62<D] QxEVD E@@ A24<2865 2?5 AC6D4C:365]Q }@H 96 :D E@J:?8 H:E9 2? 6G6? >@C6 DE6C:=6[ tDE23=:D9>6?E G6CD:@? @7 96C 42>A2:8?] pC>65 H:E9 3@F?5=6DD D6=7\2DDFC2?46[ 96VD 249:6G65 E96 ?62E EC:4< @7 D66>:?8 2E @?46 3@E9 E6A:5 2?5 9F3C:DE:4]k^Am

kAmqFE E96C6 H2D 2?@E96C[ 2C8F23=J >@C6 D6C:@FD[ AC@3=6> H:E9 $49F=EKVD G6CD:@? @7 46?EC:D>i xE 5@6D E96 @AA@D:E6 @7 H92E :E 4=2:>D E@ 5@] p A@=:E:4D :?E6?565 E@ 2AA62= E@ 2 H:56 >:55=6 @7 E96 4@F?ECJ 92D[ :? E96 92?5D @7 D@>6@?6 =:<6 $49F=EK[ 4@>6 E@ >62? 2? :?4C65:3=J ?2CC@H E9:?8i 7:D42==J 4@?D6CG2E:G6[ D@4:2==J =:36C2=[ @A6? 3@C56CD @? EC256 2?5 :>>:8C2E:@?[ C6DEC:4E:G6 @? 8F? C:89ED[ 92H<:D9 @? 7@C6:8? A@=:4J[ 2?5 ?@E 4C2KJ 23@FE C2:D:?8 E2I6D] Qr6?EC:D>[Q :? @E96C H@C5D[ 92D 364@>6 2 3JH@C5 7@C E96 A@=:E:4D @7 E96 3FD:?6DD 6=:E6] s67:?65 =67E E@ C:89E[ @? 2? I\2I:D[ :E >2J 2AAC@I:>2E6 E96 46?E6C @7 E96 A@=:E:42= DA64ECF>] qFE @? 2 J\2I:D E92E C6AC6D6?ED D@4:@64@?@>:4 DE2EFD[ :E D:ED 2E E96 G6CJ E@A]k^Am

kAmx? QuC@> E96 vC@F?5 &A[Q $49F=EK HC@E6 E92E 9:D A@=:E:42= 2H2<6?:?8 @44FCC65 ?@E 27E6C E96 6=64E:@? @7 s@?2=5 %CF>A \ @C 6G6? E92?<D E@ E96 DA64E6C @7 56>@4C2E:4 D@4:2=:D> \ 3FE :? E96 DF>>6C @7 a_``[ 5FC:?8 E96 ?@H\BF2:?E DE2?5@77 @G6C C2:D:?8 E96 563E 46:=:?8[ H96? 96 H2D 9@CC:7:65 E@ D66 E96 ?2E:@?VD 4C65:E C2E:?8 72== 7C@> ppp E@ ppZ] %9:D :D 2 3:8 E96>6 @7 9:D] x? %F4D@?[ 27E6C $49F=EK 255C6DD65 2 =64EFC6 92== 2E E96 &?:G6CD:EJ @7 pC:K@?2VD 3FD:?6DD D49@@=[ 2? 2F5:6?46 >6>36C 2D<65 9@H[ 2D AC6D:56?E[ 96 >:89E AC@>@E6 9:D G2=F6D] w6 3C@F89E FA E96 ?2E:@?2= 563E] %96 ?6IE 52J[ :? E96 3@C56C E@H? @7 }@82=6D[ DA62<:?8 E@ 2 C@@>7F= @7 |6I:42? p>6C:42? 9:89 D49@@= DEF56?ED[ 96 DEC6DD65 E96 :DDF6 @7 E96 ?2E:@?2= 563E] (96?6G6C 96 42?[ 96 E2=<D 23@FE E96 ?2E:@?2= 563E] (96? :E 4@>6D E@ 9@H 96 >:89E 255C6DD E96 Saa EC:==:@? 563E[ 96 C6D:DED E2=<:?8 23@FE C2:D:?8 E2I6D @C 4FEE:?8 >:=:E2CJ DA6?5:?8 \ EH@ 3C@25=J A@AF=2C :562D E92E >:89E @776?5 >6>36CD @7 9:D D@4:2= 4@9@CE \ 2?5 :?DE625 7@4FD6D @? 4FEE:?8 6?E:E=6>6?ED[ 2 3C@25=J F?A@AF=2C :562]k^Am

kAmxE 8@6D @?] pD<65 9@H 96V5 E24<=6 :?4@>6 :?6BF2=:EJ[ 96 D2JD 96VD D<6AE:42= @7 2 S`d >:?:>F> H286 3FE 5@6D 36=:6G6 :? QE2I C67@C>]Q w6 DFAA@CED C2:D:?8 E2I6D @? E96 C:49 3FE C67FD6D E@ D2J 9@H >F49] u@C E92E >2EE6C[ 96 E2<6D @776?D6 2E 36:?8 42==65 2 3:==:@?2:C6 2E 2==[ AC676CC:?8 E96 >@C6 8C2467F= D@3C:BF6E QA6CD@? @7 >62?D]Qk^Am

kAm$49F=EK 5@6D?VE E9:?< @7 9:>D6=7 2D 2 A=FE@4C2E] w6 8C6H FA :? AF3=:4 9@FD:?8 :? r2?2CD:6[ qC@@<=J?j 96 46CE2:?=J 92D 2 4=2:> @? @?=J\:?\p>6C:42 >6C:E@4C24J] pE E96 D2>6 E:>6[ 3642FD6 9:D 5C62>D >2E6C:2=:K65[ 96 42?VE D66> E@ 72E9@> H9J 5:D27764E65 G@E6CD \ D2J[ %CF>A @C $2?56CD DFAA@CE6CD \ >:89E 36 ?@?A=FDD65 3J 2 E9:C5\A2CEJ 42?5:524J E92E[ 7@C 2== :ED C67@C>:DE :>AF=D6D[ D4C62>D DE2EFD BF@]k^Am

kAmQw@H 3=6DD65 H6VG6 366? E@ 36 3@C? :? p>6C:42[Q $49F=EK E@=5 >6 2E @?6 A@:?E] (96? x DF886DE65 >2?J 5@?VE D66 :E E92E H2J[ 96 C6A=:65[ Q(6 92G6 E@ D9@H E96>]Q (96? x 2D<65 7@C 9:D E96@CJ @? 9@H A@=:E:4D 8@E D@ A@=2C:K65 :? E96 7:CDE A=246[ 96 86?F:?6=J 5:5?VE D66> E@ 92G6 @?6[ D6EE=:?8 6G6?EF2==J @?i Q%96 BF6DE:@? :D?VE 9@H H6 8@E 96C6] %96 BF6DE:@? :D 9@H 2C6 H6 8@:?8 E@ D@=G6 :E]Qk^Am

k46?E6CmkAmY Y Yk^Amk^46?E6Cm

kAmkDEC@?8m}@ E9:C5\A2CEJ 42?5:52E6 :? >@56C? p>6C:42? 9:DE@CJ 92D 4@>6 4=@D6 E@ H:??:?8 2 AC6D:56?E:2= 6=64E:@?]k^DEC@?8m W#@DD !6C@E 925 E96 >@DE C646?E DF446DD[ H:??:?8 `hT @7 E96 A@AF=2C G@E6 2?5 K6C@ 6=64E@C2= 4@==686 G@E6D :? `hha]X x7 $49F=EK 5@6D CF?[ 96 H@F=5 36 ECJ:?8 E@ 5@ :E @? E96 C:49\8FJ A=2E7@C>] w:D E62> 92D E9C66 86?6C2= E96@C:6D @7 9@H E@ 249:6G6 E9:D] ~?6i w@A6 E92E E96 @E96C EH@ A6@A=6 :? E96 C246 2C6 6G6? =6DD A@AF=2C E92? 96 :D] Q{6EVD D2J D@4:2=:DE G6CDFD D@4:@A2E9 :D E96 C246 :? E96 6=64E:@?[Q $E6G6 $49>:5E A@D:E65 2E @?6 A@:?E[ 2D H6 H6C6 D:EE:?8 :? E96 324< @7 E96 3FD[ H2E49:?8 E96 ?6HD] Q$@4:@A2E9 H:?D]Q $6?D:3=6 $49F=EK 42? D2G6 E96 ?2E:@? 7C@> E9:D 49@:46] qFE H92E :7 E96 s6>@4C2E:4 ?@>:?66 :D y@6 q:56?[ 2 46?E6C\=67E 42?5:52E6 56DA:D65 3J E96 q6C?:6 H:?8 @7 E96 A2CEJn Qx E9:?< q6C?:6VD 8@:?8 E@ 36 E96 ?@>:?66[Q $49>:5E C6A=:65]k^Am

kAm%96 D64@?5 DEC2E68J :?G@=G6D 9@A:?8 E96 C@F89=J c_T @7 p>6C:42?D H9@ :56?E:7J 2D :?56A6?56?ED \ >@DE @7 H9@> 5@?VE 24EF2==J G@E6 :?56A6?56?E \ H@F=5 DEC2J 7C@> E96 s6>@4C2E:4 2?5 #6AF3=:42? A2CE:6D] Q(96? J@F 8@ :?E@ 2 42>A2:8?[ J@F 92G6 E@ 36 6:E96C 492C:D>2E:4 @C 4@>A6==:?8 \ @C 3@E9[Q $49>:5E D2:5] Q!@=:E:42= =6256CD H9@ 2C6 3@E9 492C:D>2E:4 2?5 4@>A6==:?8 :D =:<6 2 @?46\:?\2\86?6C2E:@? 562=] us#] yuz] #6282?] r=:?E@?] ~32>2]Q (92EVD z2>2=2 w2CC:Dn Qr@>A6==:?8]Q (92EVD q6E@ ~V#@FC<6n Qr92C:D>2E:4]Q (92EVD $49F=EKn Qr@>A6==:?8] w6VD 8@:?8 E@ AFE 9:D DA:? @? 6?E:E=6>6?E C67@C>] w6 42? 36 3CFE2==J 9@?6DE]Qk^Am

kAm%96 E9:C5 DEC2E68J :D E@ AC2J 96 4@F=5 >2<6 D@>6 >28:4 @? E96 86?6C2= 6=64E:@? 5632E6 DE286] (96? x 2D< 7@C :?E6C?2= A@==:?8 52E2[ 9:D A@==DE6C vC68 $EC:>A=6 D6?5D >6 2 DFCG6J 96 4@>>:DD:@?65 :? y2?F2CJ[ D9@H:?8 E92E :? 9JA@E96E:42= >2E49FAD 282:?DE w2CC:D 2?5 %CF>A[ 2?5 t=:K236E9 (2CC6? 2?5 %CF>A[ $49F=EK H@F=5 82C?6C `e]g 2?5 `e]hT DFAA@CE[ C6DA64E:G6=J] %96D6 2C6 ?@E :>AC6DD:G6 ?F>36CD[ 3FE x 2DDF>6 E96J 2C6 >62?E E@ DFAA@CE E96 :562 E92E $49F=EK 92D 6?@F89 2AA62= E@ BF2=:7J 7@C AC6D:56?E:2= 5632E6D[ H9:49 C6BF:C6D 2 `dT A@==:?8 E9C6D9@=5]k^Am

kAmp7E6C 492EE:?8 H:E9 $49>:5E[ x 962565 324< E@ E96 7C@?E @7 E96 3FD[ 8C23365 2 3@EE=65 uC2AAF44:?@ @FE @7 2 >:?:\7C:586 2?5 C@56 H:E9 $49F=EK E:== %F4D@?[ H96C6 96 >6E H:E9 2?@E96C r92>36C @7 r@>>6C46[ E96? 255C6DD65 E96 pC:K@?2 |qp DEF56?ED] %96C6[ 96 925 E96 @AA@CEF?:EJ E@ C6EC246 E96 DE@CJ :? H9:49 2 D@? @7 2 5:2A6C 56=:G6CJ >2? C@D6[ 7C@> E96 8C@F?5 FA[ @FE @7 qC@@<=J?[ E@ =625 @?6 @7 E96 H@C=5VD >@DE 36=@G65 2?5 C64@8?:K23=6 3C2?5D[ H:E9 b_[___ DE@C6D :? fg :?E6C?2E:@?2= >2C<6ED] w6 E2=<65 23@FE 9@H 96 AFE A6@A=6 @G6C AC@7:ED[ 8:G:?8 6G6? 9:D A2CE\E:>6 6>A=@J66D 962=E9\42C6 36?67:ED] w6 AC@;64E65 GF=?6C23:=:EJ 23@FE E96 QD42CD[ :?D64FC:EJ 2?5 D92>6Q E92E 92G6 92F?E65 9:> D:?46 3@J9@@5] %96 4C@H5 C646:G65 9:> H2C>=J]k^Am

kAmqFE 367@C6 E92E[ H6 DE@AA65 2E 2 $E2C3F4<D @? E96 6586 @7 E@H?[ H96C6 H6 =@2565 FA @? 36G6C286D 2?5 $49F=EK 5:AA65 369:?5 E96 4@F?E6C E@ D49>@@K6 H:E9 D@>6 8C66?\2AC@?65 6>A=@J66D] w:D 3FD C6>2:?65 @FED:56[ :ED 6?8:?6 CF??:?8[ DA6H:?8 6I92FDE 2?5 4C62E:?8 2? :?4C65:3=6 C24<6E] %96 ?@:D6 42FD65 2 8FJ H:E9 5:CEJ\3=@?5 92:C :? 2 E2EE6C65 &?:G6CD:EJ @7 pC:K@?2 %\D9:CE E@ 9FDE=6 @FE @7 9:D D>2== 9@>6[ ;FDE 369:?5 E96 $E2C3F4<D A2C<:?8 =@E[ 2?5 >2?:242==J 2D< 7@C D@>6@?6[ 2?J@?6[ E@ A=62D6 EFC? @77 E96 :8?:E:@?] x 2D<65 2 DE2776C :7 E9:D >:89E 36 A@DD:3=6[ 3FE 96 H2D @44FA:65 u246%:>:?8 9:D 52F89E6C]k^Am

kAm%96 8FJ 6G6?EF2==J 82G6 FA] pD 96 DE2=<65 324< E@ 9:D 9@FD6[ x E@=5 9:> H9@D6 3FD :E H2D] w6 C68:DE6C65 E96 :?7@C>2E:@? H:E9@FE 3C62<:?8 DEC:56] Qx 92E6 =:G:?8 369:?5 2 $E2C3F4<D[Q 96 D2:5]k^Am

k46?E6CmkAmY Y Yk^Amk^46?E6Cm

kAmkDEC@?8mp>:5 E96 C2?4@C @7 E96 =2E6 v6@C86 (] qFD9 J62CD[k^DEC@?8m 2 BF:I@E:4 ?6H A2DD:@? 7@C 46?EC:D> DE2CE65 3FC3=:?8 FA 7C@> E96 A@=:E:42= 3@8] %96C6 H2D &?:EJ_g[ H9:49 F?DF446DD7F==J EC:65 E@ 5C27E 2 3:A2CE:D2? QF?:EJ E:4<6EQ 7@C AC6D:56?E] %92E 6G@=G65 :?E@ p>6C:42?D t=64E[ 2 Sbd >:==:@? 3:5 324<65 3J 96586\7F?5 >@?6J E@ 5@ E96 D2>6 E9:?8] %92E 72:=65 E@@] }6IE 42>6 E96 r6?EC:DE !C@;64E[ H9:49 D@F89E E@ 6=64E 46?EC:DE :?56A6?56?ED E@ E96 &]$] $6?2E6] %92E 5:5?VE H@C< 6:E96C[ 2?5 E96 @C82?:K2E:@? 492?865 :ED ?2>6 2?5 >:DD:@?] Q%96 H@C5 V46?EC:DEV :D =@2565] xEVD A6C46:G65 2D DE2EFD BF@[ @C DA=:E E96 5:776C6?46[Q D2JD }:4< %C@:2?@[ E96 6I64FE:G6 5:C64E@C @7 H92E :D ?@H &?:E6 p>6C:42[ H9:49 92D D9:7E65 E@ DFAA@CE:?8 >@56C2E6 #6AF3=:42?D 2?5 s6>@4C2ED :? AC:>2CJ C246D] Q%96 3C2?5 :D BF:E6 E@I:4]Qk^Am

kAmxEVD ECF6] %96C6VD 2 C62D@? 7@C>6C }6H *@C< |2J@C |:4926= q=@@>36C8[ E96 3:==:@?2:C6 46?EC:DE A2C 6I46==6?46[ 4@?D:DE6?E=J C67FD6D E@ CF? 7@C AC6D:56?E] u24E@C :? E96 C:D6 @7 @FED:56 AC6DDFC6 8C@FAD[ 86CCJ>2?56C65 4@?8C6DD:@?2= 5:DEC:4ED 2?5 92EC65 @7 E96 @E96C E62> \ 2?5 E96C6VD 2 =@E @7 :?46?E:G6 7@C 42?5:52E6D E@ 2G@:5 E96 D@7E >:55=6] %92E D2:5[ E96 a_`g >:5E6C>D H6C6 56E6C>:?65 ?@E 3J $2?56CD\324<65 AC@8C6DD:G6D 3FE 3J >:55=6\@7\E96\C@25 =:36C2=D[ H9@ 7=:AA65 5@K6?D @7 D62ED] r6?EC:DED >2J 36 6IE:?4E :? E96 4FCC6?E #6AF3=:42? !2CEJ[ 3FE E96C6 2C6 DE:== A=6?EJ 2>@?8 s6>@4C2ED] %96 AC6D:56?E:2= 7:6=5 :D DE24<65 H:E9 A6@A=6 C@FE:?6=J E2CC65 2D >@56C2E6D 3J E96:C =67E\H:?8 @AA@?6?ED[ :?4=F5:?8 r@CJ q@@<6C[ !6E6 qFEE:8:68[ q6E@ ~V#@FC<6[ p>J z=@3F492C[ z:CDE6? v:==:3C2?5[ y@9? w:4<6?=@@A6C 2?5 y@6 q:56?[ E96 s6>@4C2E:4 7C@?E\CF??6C] x7 @?6 D66D p>6C:42? A@=:E:4D 2D 2 562E9 >2E49 36EH66? s@?2=5 %CF>A 2?5 p=6I2?5C:2 ~42D:@\r@CE6K[ E96? J6D[ E96C6 :D ?@ 46?E6C] qFE E92E G:6H :D 4=62C=J HC@?8]k^Am

kAm%96 AC@3=6>[ A6C92AD[ :D?VE E96 46?E6C 2D DF49] xEVD H92E Q46?EC:D>Q 92D 4@>6 E@ C6AC6D6?E] %96 >@DE AC@>:?6?E @7 E96 3:8 46?EC:DE :?E6C6DE 8C@FAD[ }@ {236=D[ H2D 7@F?565 :? a_`_ E@ Q25G@42E6 2?5 65F42E6 7@C 8C62E6C 3:A2CE:D2? 4@@A6C2E:@? E9C@F89 2== =6G6=D @7 8@G6C?>6?E]Q (9:=6 E96 8C@FA DFAA@CED D@>6 AC@8C6DD:G6 AC@A@D2=D[ =:<6 DF3D:5:K65 72>:=J =62G6[ :ED @C:6?E2E:@? E@H2C5 4@CA@C2E6\7C:6?5=J A@=:E:4D :D F?>:DE2<23=6] p 9F86 A2CE @7 H92E :E 5@6D :D 32?<C@== AC@\3FD:?6DD 42?5:52E6D @7 3@E9 A2CE:6D] {2DE 4J4=6[ D:I }@ {236=D\277:=:2E65 DFA6C !prD C2:D65 S`` >:==:@? 7C@> ;FDE db 5@?@CD] p44@C5:?8 E@ 5@4F>6?ED =62<65 E@ E96 s2:=J q62DE =2DE J62C[ :ED 7F?56CD :?4=F56 q2:? r2A:E2= rt~ y@D9 q6<6?DE6:?[ (2=>2CE 96:C6DD r9C:DEJ #FE9 (2=E@? 2?5 @E96C G6CJ C:49 A6@A=6] W(96? x 2D<65 }@ {236=D 7@F?56C }2?4J y24@3D@? H96E96C E96 8C@FA H2D 369@=56? E@ :ED H62=E9J 5@?@CD[ D96 D2:5[ Qx 92G6 ?6G6C 962C5 2?J @?6 @7 E96D6 A6@A=6 6G6C 2D< 7@C 2?JE9:?8 A6CD@?2= 7@C E96>D6=G6D]Q }@ {236=D[ D96 25565[ :D QAFC6[ :EVD 7@C E9:D 4@F?ECJ[ 2?5 E92EVD E96 @?=J E9:?8 E92EVD 5C:G:?8 2?J3@5J]QXk^Am

kAm%9:D DA64:6D @7 46?EC:DE[ 2=D@ <?@H? 2D 2 Q4@CA@C2E6 s6>@4C2E[Q :D AC@323=J 36DE 6>3@5:65 3J 7@C>6C $6?] y@6 {:636C>2? @7 r@??64E:4FE WH9@ D6CG6D @? E96 }@ {236=D 3@2C5X] QxEVD 7:D42= C6DA@?D:3:=:EJ[ :EVD AC@\8C@HE9[ :EVD 2 <:?5 @7 AC:?4:A=65 :?E6C?2E:@?2=:D>[Q {:636C>2? E@=5 >6 H96? x 2D<65 9:> E@ =2J @FE 9:D G:D:@? @7 46?EC:D>] {:636C>2? C646?E=J C68:DE6C65 2D 2 =@33J:DE 7@C E96 r9:?6D6 E6=64@> 8:2?E +%t[ H9:49 96 @?46 42==65 2 ?2E:@?2= D64FC:EJ E9C62Ej 96VD 2=D@ 2 =2HJ6C 2E E96 7:C> CF? 3J 7@C>6C %CF>A 2EE@C?6J |2C4 z2D@H:EK] W{:636C>2? E@=5 !@=:E:4@ 96VD >6C6=J Q=:DE6?:?8 2?5 2D<:?8 BF6DE:@?DQ @? 3692=7 @7 +%t]Xk^Am

kAm{:636C>2?[ $49F=EK[ }@ {236=D 2?5 @E96CD H9@ D92C6 E96:C G:6HD 92G6 >2?2865 E@ >@?@A@=:K6 E96 Q46?EC:DEQ 2?5 Q:?56A6?56?EQ E28D] qFE E2<6 2?J >@56DE=J DF446DD7F= E9:C5\A2CEJ AC6D:56?E:2= 42?5:52E6 @7 E96 A2DE 46?EFCJi %96J =@@< ?@E9:?8 =:<6 $49F=EK] tF86?6 s63D H2D 2 D@4:2=:DE] %96@5@C6 #@@D6G6=E H2D 2 ECFDE3FDE6C] #@36CE {2 u@==6EE6 H2D 2 AC@8C6DD:G6] #@DD !6C@E H2D 2 EC256 92H<] p== H6C6 A@AF=:DED] pD H2D q6C?:6 $2?56CD] p?5 2D H2D s@?2=5 %CF>A] #2E96C E92? 25@AE E96 A@=:E:4D @7 E96 7:?2?4:2= @C A@=:E:42= 6=:E6[ 2== A@CEC2J65 E96>D6=G6D[ :? @?6 H2J @C 2?@E96C[ 2D @FED:56CD[ 7:89E:?8 @? E96 D:56 @7 E96 =:EE=6 8FJ \ H9:49 :D H96C6 E96 24EF2= 46?E6C C6D:56D]k^Am

kAmx? a_`f[ }6H p>6C:42 u@F?52E:@? 76==@H {66 sCFE>2? AF3=:D965 2 72D4:?2E:?8 2?5 H:56=J C625 DEF5J @7 E96 a_`e 6=64E:@?] w6 5:G:565 E96 6=64E@C2E6 :?E@ 7@FC 8C@FADi =:36C2=D[ 4@?D6CG2E:G6D[ =:36CE2C:2?D 2?5[ 4CF4:2==J[ A@AF=:DED] %96D6 H6C6 G@E6CD H9@ =62?65 =:36C2= :? 64@?@>:4D[ 3FE 4@?D6CG2E:G6 @? :56?E:EJ :DDF6D] w6 7@F?5 E92E r=:?E@?[ C6=J:?8 2=>@DE 6?E:C6=J @? =:36C2=D[ 4@F=5?VE 42CCJ E96 6=64E:@?] %CF>A G@E6CD[ 3J 4@?EC2DE[ H6C6 DA=:E 36EH66? 4@?D6CG2E:G6D 2?5 A@AF=:DED] %9@F89 96 E649?:42==J C2? 2D 2 #6AF3=:42?[ %CF>A FD65 2? F?@CE9@5@I >2D9\FA @7 =67E\H:?8 W2?E:\7C66\EC256X 2?5 C:89E\H:?8 W2?E:\:>>:8C2?EX DE2?46D E@ 2EEC24E G@E6CD 5:DD2E:D7:65 H:E9 E96 A@=:E:42= 6DE23=:D9>6?E] x? 9:D @H? 6IEC6>6 H2J[ 96 C2? 2D 2 >@56C2E6] (9:49 96=AD 6IA=2:? H9J `aT @7 q6C?:6 $2?56CD AC:>2CJ G@E6CD E96? G@E65 7@C %CF>A[ 2?5 H9J hT @7 %CF>A G@E6CD 925 AC6G:@FD=J G@E65 7@C ~32>2]k^Am

kAmp>6C:42? DH:?8 G@E6CD E6?5 ?@E E@ D92C6 E96 A@=:E:4D @7 u@CEF?6 d__ rt~D] %96 ?2E:@?VD 4C65:E C2E:?8 5@6D ?@E <66A E96> FA 2E ?:89E] Q$49F=EK 92D 4@>A=6E6=J >:DC625 E96 >@>6?E] w6VD >:DC625:?8 E96 46?E6C @7 E96 6=64E@C2E6[Q D2JD y@?2E92? r@H2?[ E96 AC6D:56?E @7 %9:C5 (2J[ 2 s6>@4C2E:4 E9:?< E2?< E92E :ED6=7 92D 366? 56C:565 2D 3=2?5 2?5 >:55=6\@7\E96\C@25] Q%96C6 :D K6C@ 492?46 @7 9:> H:??:?8 E96 6=64E:@? 2D 2? :?56A6?56?E] {:E6C2==J ?@E A@DD:3=6]Q u@C w@H2C5 $49F=EK E@ A:4< @77 6?@F89 765\FA[ ?@?A2CE:D2? G@E6CD E@ CF? 2 4@>A6E:E:G6 C246[ 96V5 AC@323=J 92G6 E@ 42>A2:8? 2D E96 @AA@D:E6 @7 9:>D6=7]k^Am

k46?E6CmkAmY Y Yk^Amk^46?E6Cm

kAmkDEC@?8mQr2? x AFE E96D6 366CD @77 E96 C64@C5nQk^DEC@?8mk^Am

kAmxE H2D `_ic_ 2]>] :? E96 $E2E6? xD=2?5 u6CCJ E6C>:?2=[ 2?5 ba\J62C\@=5 s6>@4C2E:4 &]$] #6A] |2I #@D6 H2D C6249:?8 7@C EH@ E2==\3@J qC@@<=J? x!pD @FE @7 2? :46 3F4<6E 2E 2 A:KK2 <:@D<] x E@=5 9:> ?@[ 2?5 96 8C23365 E96> 2?JH2J] (6 925 23@FE a_ >:?FE6D F?E:= 96 925 E@ E@FC E96 8C@F?5D @7 2 ?6H D9@AA:?8 46?E6C] (6 4C24<65 E96 366CD 2?5 5C2?<]k^Am

kAm(92E H@F=5 2 G:23=6 G6CD:@? @7 w@H2C5 $49F=EK =@@< =:<6n }@E 2 Q4@CA@C2E6 s6>@4C2EQ 3FE 2 QA@AF=:DE 46?EC:DE]Q %@ 7:?5 @?6[ x =@@<65 7@C s6>@4C2ED H9@ 925 7=:AA65 #6AF3=:42?\96=5[ %CF>A\G@E:?8 4@?8C6DD:@?2= 5:DEC:4ED :? E96 a_`g >:5E6C>D] ~FE @7 cbd C246D[ a` 7:E E9:D 56D4C:AE:@?] (:E9:? E96D6[ x =@@<65 7@C FAD6EDi s6>@4C2E:4 G:4E@C:6D :? C6=:23=6 #6AF3=:42? 5:DEC:4ED E92E 5:5?VE 7=:A E92?<D E@ AC65:4E23=6 2?E:\%CF>A C624E:@?] %96C6 H6C6 @?=J 2 92?57F= \ A6C92AD ?@?6 >@C6 DFCAC:D:?8 E92? }6H *@C< r:EJVD ``E9[ 6?4@>A2DD:?8 2== @7 $E2E6? xD=2?5 2?5 2 D=:G6C @7 D@FE9 qC@@<=J?[ 2 5:DEC:4E E92E %CF>A 9:>D6=7 925 42CC:65 3J `_ A@:?ED EH@ J62CD 62C=:6C] #@D6[ 2 A@=:E:42= ?6@A9JE6[ :D :ED 4@?8C6DD>2? \ 2?5 A6C92AD @FC A6C764E A@AF=:DE 46?EC:DE]k^Am

kAmx 7:CDE ?@E:465 #@D6 :? E96 DF>>6C @7 a_`g[ H96? 9:D %' 25D DE2CE65 E@ A@A FA @? }*`[ }6H *@C<VD 2==\52J ?6HD 492??6=] $9@CE[ 32=5 2?5 32CC6=\496DE65] p 9F>2? E6CC:6C] %96 25D 6>A92D:K65 9:D 2AAC@24923:=:EJ 2?5 4@??64E:@? E@ @C5:?2CJ p>6C:42?D W9:D >:=:E2CJ D6CG:46[ 9:D A6?492?E 7@C D:?8:?8 Q!:E49 !6C764EQ D@?8DX 2?5 H6C6 2=>@DE 4@>:42==J ?@?:56@=@8:42=] }@ >6?E:@? @7 9:D A@=:E:42= A2CEJ] #@D6 ;FDE 92>>6C65 E96 :562 E92E $E2E6? xD=2?56CD 925 366? =67E 369:?5 3J 6=:E6D F?:?E6C6DE65 :? E96:C AC@3=6>D[ 7C@> EC277:4 E@ @A:@:5 255:4E:@?] Q|2J@C 56 q=2D:@ 24ED =:<6 $E2E6? xD=2?5 5@6D?VE 6G6? 6I:DE] p?5 H6 ?665 E@ 86E C:5 @7 2== E96 =6256CD9:A :? s]r][Q 96 ?2CC2E65] Q(92EVD E96 6DE23=:D9>6?E 5@:?8 7@C J@FnQk^Am

kAmx 5:5?VE <?@H H92E E@ 6IA64E 7C@> #@D6] w:D 3:@8C2A9J :D F?@CE9@5@I] w6 62C?65 2 !FCA=6 w62CE :? p7892?:DE2?] w6 C67FD65 E@ E2<6 4@CA@C2E6 !pr >@?6J :? 9:D 6=64E:@?] w6VD 8@E 2 =F?49\A2:= G:36 E92E >2<6D 9:> 2 ?2EFC2= 7:E H:E9 $E2E6? xD=2?5VD H6==\5@4F>6?E65 A@AF=2E:@? @7 A@=:46 @77:46CD[ 7:C67:89E6CD 2?5 4:EJ H@C<6CD] w6 2=D@ 8C6H FA :? !2C< $=@A6[ H6?E E@ (6D=6J2? 2?5 @?46 :?E6C?65 7@C r@CJ q@@<6C] (92E 96 =@DE :? 4@CA@C2E6 42D9 96 >256 FA 7@C :? @FE\@7\5:DEC:4E 5@?2E:@?D]k^Am

kAmx >6E FA H:E9 #@D6 @?6 H66<52J >@C?:?8 @FED:56 2 DF3H2J DE2E:@? :? q2J #:586[ qC@@<=J?[ 2D 96 92?565 @FE 7=J6CD 2?5 <:3:EK65 H:E9 4@>>FE6CD] w6 H2D :?D2?6=J 8@@5 2E E9:D] %96C6 H2D ?@ H2J E@ E6== 7C@> 9:D :?E6C24E:@?D :7 96V5 <?@H? D@>6@?6 D:?46 49:=59@@5 @C ?6G6C D66? E96> 367@C6] {@ED @7 3C@\9F8D H6C6 AC@776C65] qFE E96 7:CDE DF3DE2?E:G6 :?E6C24E:@? x D2H H2D 2 D=:89E=J 4@?E6?E:@FD @?6[ 2?5 2 8@@5 H:?5@H :?E@ 9:D A@=:E:4D]k^Am

kAmp 76H >:?FE6D 27E6C x 8@E E96C6[ 2 =:EE=6 367@C6 g 2]>][ 2 b_\:D9 H@>2? H:E9 2 Q!@5 $2G6 p>6C:42Q DE:4<6C @? 96C E96C>@D W@C 324<A24<[ @C 3:<6 96=>6E[ x 42?VE C6>6>36CX DE2CE65 E@ 8C:== 9:> 23@FE H96E96C 96 DFAA@CED ~42D:@\r@CE6KVD vC66? }6H s62=] t>A92E:42==J[ 96 5@6D ?@E] Qx E9:?< E96 64@?@>:4 AC:?4:A=6D :? E96C6 2C6 23D@=FE6=J C:5:4F=@FD[ 23D@=FE6=J C:5:4F=@FD[Q 96 E@=5 96C] QxV> E96 >@DE AC@\F?:@? 8FJ 2C@F?5] x E9:?< :EVD C62==J 2 5:776C6?46 :? F?56CDE2?5:?8 @7 9@H H6 H2?E E@ 86E E96C6 >@C6 E92? 2?JE9:?8 6=D6] y@3D 8F2C2?E66n |2<6D ?@ D6?D6 H92ED@6G6C] +6C@ D6?D6]Q tG6?EF2==J[ D96 5F4<65 :?E@ E96 DF3H2J[ 2?5 #@D6[ H9@ 925 2=C625J C:3365 >6 7@C D9@H:?8 FA cd >:?FE6D =2E6C E92? 96 5:5 \ xV5 72:= @FE @7 E96 >:=:E2CJ[ H2D E96 :>A=:42E:@? \ EFC?65 >J H2J] Q%92EVD H9J J@F 7\65 FA] x H2D 2== <:DD:?8 323:6D 367@C6 J@F 8@E 96C6[ 2?5 ?@H x 86E :?E@ 2? :?E6==64EF2= 5632E6] $96 ;F>A65 2== @G6C >6]Qk^Am

kAm#@D6 >2J ?@E D92C6 E96 6I24E A@=:E:4D @7 9:D 56=682E:@? >6>36C 2?5 76==@H 7C6D9>2? ~42D:@\r@CE6K[ 3FE 96 2=D@ 5@6D?VE :56?E:7J H:E9 E96 ?6@=:36C2=:D> @7 E96 A2DE 86?6C2E:@? @7 E96 s6>@4C2E:4 !2CEJ] Q}@H[ H92E H6 42??@E 5@ :D D2J E96 4@F?E6C32=2?46 E@ ,D@4:2=:D>. :D |:EE #@>?6J[ r=:?E@?6DBF6 EC:2?8F=2E:@?[ >@56C2E:@?[ J@F <?@H[ 3F==D\[Q 96 D2:5[ 27E6C 2? @3=:82E@CJ 5:?6C DE@A] Q(96C6 J@F E9:?< 6G6CJE9:?8 42? 36 D@=G65 H:E9 2 AF3=:4\AC:G2E6 A2CE?6CD9:A]Q x? 724E[ 96 2?5 ~42D:@\r@CE6K AC@323=J 2C6?VE 72C 2A2CE @? >@DE :DDF6Di #@D6 DFAA@CED 2 AF3=:4 962=E9\42C6 @AE:@?[ H2?ED E@ =@H6C E96 286 @7 |65:42C6 6=:8:3:=:EJ E@ dd[ 2?5 G@42==J DFAA@CED E96 F?:@?:K2E:@? @7 $E2E6? xD=2?5VD p>2K@? 7F=7:==>6?E 46?E6C] Wp>2K@? rt~ y677 q6K@D @H?D %96 (2D9:?8E@? !@DE]Xk^Am

kAmp H66< 62C=:6C[ 2E 2 E@H? 92== 6G6?E :? 2 49FC49 :? 2 {2E:?@ ?6:893@C9@@5 @7 $E2E6? xD=2?5[ x D2H 9:> >2<6 2?@E96C :?E6C6DE:?8 A:G@E] p7E6C 2 H@>2? 2D<65 9:> :7 96 DFAA@CE65 E96 sC62> p4E WJ6DX[ 2 8FJ :? 2 C65 7=2??6= D9:CE 2?5 2 D?@HJ H9:E6 362C5 2D<65 9:> H96E96C 96 DFAA@CED %CF>AVD 3@C56C H2== W?@X] %96 >2? H6?E @? E@ D2J E92E 96VD H@C<65 :? 4@?DECF4E:@? 7@C c_ J62CD 2?5 E92E :EVD :>A@DD:3=6 ?@E E@ D66 E96 67764E @7 :==682= :>>:8C2E:@? @? E96 3F:=5:?8 EC256D] Q(286D 5C@AA65] $BF66K65 @FE ?2E:G6\3@C? >6?[ H9:E6[ 3=24< 2?5 3C@H?] %9:D 4@>>F?:EJ 92D =@DE ;@3D 3642FD6 @7 E92E]Q #@D6 E92?<65 9:> 7@C 5C2H:?8 Q2EE6?E:@? E@ E96 64@?@>:4 A=:89E @7 E96 H@C<:?8 4=2DDQ 367@C6 >2<:?8 2 42D6 \ 56D:8?65 E@ 2AA62= E@ 9:D :?E6C=@4FE@C \ 7@C 2 A2E9H2J E@ 4:E:K6?D9:A] QvF6DD H92EVD 8@:?8 E@ 92AA6? H:E9 E92E 5@4F>6?E2E:@?[Q 96 D2:5] Qx H2?E 2 F?:@? 42C5 2EE24965 E@ :E]Qk^Am

kAm#@D6VD 5:DEC:4E :D 72D4:?2E:?8] }@E @?=J H2D $E2E6? xD=2?5 E96 @?=J 4@F?EJ :? }6H *@C< r:EJ E@ 8@ 7@C %CF>A :? E96 86?6C2=[ 3FE :E G@E65 7@C %CF>A :? E96 #6AF3=:42? AC:>2CJ 2E 2 9:896C C2E6 WgaTX E92? 2?J @E96C 4@F?EJ :? E96 DE2E6] pE E96 D2>6 E:>6[ #@D6VD 5:DEC:4E :D @?6 @7 E96 >@C6 56>@8C2A9:42==J C6AC6D6?E2E:G6 :? p>6C:42i `bT {2E:?@[ `aT pD:2?[ fT 3=24<[ efT H9:E6] s6>@4C2ED @FE?F>36C #6AF3=:42?D d E@ b[ 3FE 367@C6 #@D6 :E H2D C6AC6D6?E65 :? r@?8C6DD 3J E96 3=29 #6AF3=:42? s2? s@?@G2?[ 2?5 367@C6 E92E[ E96 ?@E\2E\2== 3=29 #6AF3=:42? |:4926= vC:>>[ H9@ 5:5 2 DE:?E :? 7656C2= AC:D@? 7@C E2I 6G2D:@?] xEVD 2 5:DEC:4E 5@>:?2E65 3J #6282? s6>@4C2ED H9@ G@E6 #6AF3=:42?[ ?@E 3642FD6 E96JVC6 92C54@C6 4@?D6CG2E:G6D[ 3FE 3642FD6 >@DE s6>@4C2ED D66> F?C6=2E23=6[ =:36C2= 2?5 DBF:D9J] Wq:== 56 q=2D:@ :D 56DA:D65 @? $E2E6? xD=2?5]Xk^Am

kAm#@D6VD A6CD@?2=:EJ A=2JD H6== :? E96 5:DEC:4E] x? E96 92=7\52J H6 DA6?E E@86E96C[ 96 WpX 4=2:>65 96 4@F=5 H:? 2 C246 :? ~42D:@\r@CE6KVD 5:DEC:4E[ H9:49 4@G6CD A2CED @7 E96 qC@?I 2?5 "F66?Dj WqX 244FD65 >6 @7 36:?8 QC6=2E:G6=J 2CC@82?EQ 27E6C x 42==65 9:> 2 QC6=2E:G6 ?6H4@>6CQ E@ $E2E6? xD=2?5j 2?5 WrX 3@F89E FD >@C?:?8 366CD] qFE 9:D H@C=5G:6H 2=D@ C67=64ED E96 s6>@4C2E:4 A=2J3@@< @7 E96 a_`g >:5E6C>D \ 5@>:?2E65 3J >@56C2E6D H9@ H6C6?VE ?646DD2C:=J 2?@5J?6 2?5 3FD:?6DD 7C:6?5=J]k^Am

kAm{:<6 #@D6[ 2 ?F>36C @7 @E96C s6>@4C2E:4 7C6D9>6? 2C6 G6E6C2?D @7 E96 H2CD :? xC2B 2?5 p7892?:DE2?[ H9:49 >2J 36 2?@E96C H2J E96J 2AA62=65 E@ C:89E\H:?8 G@E6CD H:E9@FE 2=:6?2E:?8 =67E\H:?8 G@E6CD] #@D6VD 5:DEC:4E :D E96 @?=J @?6 :? E96 4@F?ECJ E92E H6?E 7@C |4r2:? :? a__g 2?5 ~32>2 :? a_`a] Q*@F 5@?VE 86E >@C6 A2EC:@E:4 E92? y@9? |4r2:?[Q #@D6 D2:5[ 6IA=2:?:?8 E96 2?@>2=J] Q%96 72E96C @7 42>A2:8? 7:?2?46 C67@C>] %96 >2G6C:4<]Qk^Am

kAm#@D6 C2? E@ E96 =67E @7 :?4F>36?E s@?@G2? @? 6G6CJ D:?8=6 :DDF6] r=:>2E6 492?86[ 23@CE:@?[ D2?4EF2CJ 4:E:6D[ J@F ?2>6 :E] qFE E9:D 5:5?VE A@D6 2 AC@3=6> E@ 7=:AA:?8 9:D 5:DEC:4E] w6 C6AC6D6?ED }6H *@C<[ ?@E CFC2= |2:?6 @C !6??DJ=G2?:2 DE66= 4@F?ECJ] x?DE625[ 96 D:>A=J E24<65 >2:?DEC62> @? E9:C5\C2:= E@A:4D \ ?@ p3@=:D9 xrt[ ?@ D@4:2=:D> \ E96? @FE\%CF>A65 %CF>A @? A@4<6E3@@< :DDF6D] Q!FE :>>:8C2E:@? 2D:56] *@F <?@H[ s@?2=5 %CF>A 4@\@AE65 2 s6>@4C2E:4 64@?@>:4 A@AF=:DE 286?52 :? D@>6 H2JD[Q #@D6 D2:5] Qw6 E2=<65 23@FE E96 42CC:65\:?E6C6DE =@@A9@=6] w6 E2=<65 23@FE 9@H A:E:7F= @FC C@25D 2?5 3C:586D H6C6[ 2?5 9@H H6VC6 8@??2 >2<6 E96> 8C62E 282:?] #:89En w6 DA@<6 23@FE AC@E64E:?8 $@4:2= $64FC:EJ 2?5 |65:42C6[ 2?5 3F:=5:?8 FA@? E96> 6G6?] qFE E96 AC@3=6> :D H6 92G6?VE D66? E96> 5@?6] w6 E2=<65 23@FE H2JD :? H9:49 7C66 EC256 \ H6 2== AC2J E@ E9:D v@5[ V2== 3@2ED C:D:?8]V xEVD 2? 64@?@>:4 72==24J] w6 E@=5 FD E96 ECFE9] (6VC6 86EE:?8 C:AA65 @77]Qk^Am

kAmxV> ?@E DFC6 H92E #@D6VD A@=:E:42= 7FEFC6 9@=5D \ 2?5 96VD 2=C625J 8@E D6G6C2= #6AF3=:42? 492==6?86CD =:?65 FA E@ E2<6 9:> @? :? a_a_] qFE H96E96C #@D6 6G6C 7:?5D 9:>D6=7 2 >2;@C ?2E:@?2= A=2E7@C>[ 9:D 3C2?5 @7 A@=:E:4D :D H@CE9 E2<:?8 D6C:@FD=J] u@C 2== :ED 6G:56?E =2>6?6DD[ E96C6 :D 2 AFCA@D6 E@ 46?EC:D>] (:E9@FE D@>6 <:?5 @7 4@?D6?DFD 36EH66? @AA@D:?8 724E:@?D[ 56>@4C24J 462D6D E@ H@C<] p>6C:42 @3G:@FD=J ?665D 2 >:55=6] xE ;FDE >:89E ?@E 36 E96 @?6 w@H2C5 $49F=EK H2?ED]k^Am